ThredUp vs. Poshmark: Which Fits Your Closet Cleanout Goals?

‍

It’s easier than ever to declutter your wardrobe—all you have to do is bag up your clothes and ship them off. While there are countless secondhand online clothing shops, from Mercari to TheRealReal, it often comes down to ThredUp or Poshmark.

Both platforms offer a smart, eco-friendly way to clean out your closet, earn extra cash, and score a few new treasured pieces—but they work differently.

So which one is best for you? Read on to compare ThredUp versus Poshmark for buyers and sellers. 

What’s ThredUp and how does it work?

ThredUp is an online consignment store that makes it easy to buy and sell preloved clothing. The ThredUp team manages the entire selling process for you—just bag up your clothes, and ThredUp will photograph, list, and ship them while you sit back and enjoy the payout.

As one of the largest resale platforms, ThredUp has processed 172 million garments from over 55,000 brands across 100 categories. With around 17 million pieces resold each year, countless clothing items stay out of landfills and in circulation. By making online thrifting straightforward and accessible, ThredUp empowers anyone to embrace sustainable fashion, whether you’re buying or selling.

ThredUp also uses AI technology to create a smoother, more enjoyable experience, allowing us to efficiently sort, price, and sell items while helping you find exactly what you’re looking for. Our Improved Search understands natural language, so you can browse using casual phrases. And with Style Chat, you get a personal stylist who provides outfit inspiration and helps you build a wardrobe you love.

What’s Poshmark and how does it work?

Poshmark is a resale marketplace for clothing, accessories, and home goods. Their community is massive, with over 80 million users and 200 million product listings. But selling on Poshmark requires more hands-on effort than ThredUp: You photograph your items, write descriptions, set prices, and handle shipping once something sells. 

This platform is popular for buying and selling men’s, women’s, and children’s clothes. Poshmark primarily accepts trendy brands, focusing on designer bags and clothes, but you can also list miscellaneous items like toys and pet clothes. 

Poshmark’s largest draw is their app, which appeals to thrifters looking for a social shopping experience. Sellers create virtual closets to display items and participate in Posh Parties to promote listings. For many users, the platform feels part resale site, part social network. 

Is ThredUp or Poshmark better? Pros, cons, and facts

While ThredUp and Poshmark are both popular picks for buying and selling secondhand clothes, they cater to different needs and selling styles.

At a glance

Getting started

Let’s see how easy it is to create an account and start thrifting with each platform.

ThredUp

Head to ThredUp and click the person icon in the right-hand corner. Click Sign Up and choose your preferred method—you can enter an email or use your existing Google, Amazon, Facebook, or Apple account.

That’s it! You’re now ready to start adding preloved treasures to your cart, or you can click the Sell tab to order a Clean Out bag (more on that later).

Poshmark

Visit Poshmark’s main page and sign up with Facebook, Google, Apple, or email. Next, click Sell on Poshmark at the top of the page to start listing, or use the search bar to browse items. This process is the same for the web version and mobile app.

Item categories

Whether you’re shopping or selling, here are the items each platform supports.

ThredUp

ThredUp accepts women’s and children’s clothing and accessories, and each section has multiple subcategories. For example, “jeans” contains dozens of options, from skinnies to straight legs. 

Main categories include:

• Dresses
• Tops and sweaters
• Pants and jeans
• Swimwear 
• Activewear
• Handbags
• Footwear

ThredUp is ideal for buying and selling designer clothes and supports a range of sizes, like maternity, petite, and plus-size. 

Poshmark

Poshmark accepts a broader variety of items but prioritizes designer fashion. Here are the main types of products you can list and buy:

• Women’s clothing
• Men’s clothing
• Kids’ clothing
• Accessories
• Home goods
• Electronics
• Pet items
• Cosmetics

If you’re selling makeup or tech, read Poshmark’s policies carefully. They have strict rules to ensure safety and peace of mind.

{{inline-banner}}

Selling items

Both platforms let you turn closet cleanouts into cash—all from the comfort of home. Here’s how the selling process compares.

ThredUp

ThredUp makes selling clothes online effortless. Order a Clean Out bag, fill it with gently used clothing and accessories, and send it back using the prepaid shipping label. You don’t pay any upfront fees.

You can monitor your items from your ThredUp dashboard, collecting earnings as soon as something sells. If no one buys an item, you can reclaim it or leave it to us—we’ll do our best to give it a new life.

For more info, check out ThredUp reviews to read stories and experiences from happy customers.

Poshmark

Poshmark has a standard selling process similar to eBay and Mercari. While they offer a high level of control, more manual effort makes this platform best for dedicated sellers rather than casual thrifters.

You’ll need to take photos, create a listing, and write a detailed description. Once an item sells, Poshmark provides a prepaid shipping label so you can package the item and send it off. You receive earnings once the buyer accepts the package.

Profit and payout options

Here’s a quick summary of the profit you’ll earn selling on ThredUp versus Poshmark, plus a look at the payout options:

ThredUp

On ThredUp, you earn a percentage of the selling price and can receive earnings through three payout options: 

• Store credit
• PayPal transfer
• Stripe bank transfer

All options are quick and easy, but you get a bonus by choosing store credit—enjoy a 10% to 15% boost to your profits for specific brands, including Vera Bradley, Banana Republic, and Hollister.

Poshmark

Poshmark takes a flat fee of $2.95 for items you sell under $15 and a 20% commission for all other sales. They provide five payout options:

• Instant bank transfer
• PayPal
• Venmo 
• Direct deposit 
• Check

Each option has different deposit times and associated fees.

Thrift smarter and faster: Why ThredUp makes selling simple

ThredUp and Poshmark are both eco-friendly ways to refresh your closet—the best option just comes down to your preferences. While Poshmark is excellent for people with their own fashion side hustle, ThredUp is a great choice for anyone who values speed and convenience. 

Reselling on ThredUp couldn’t be easier—order a Clean Out bag, fill it up, and send it back. It’s the perfect way for casual thrifters and first-time sellers to tidy up their wardrobes and earn extra cash without the time commitment.

ThredUp is the ideal platform for buyers, too. You can use our AI-powered search features to find the perfect item in any size or color, renewing your closet with just a few clicks. New to thrifting on ThredUp? Use code FIRST50 to get 50% off your first order (plus free shipping).

FAQs

What’s the best online thrift store?

While “best” depends on your preferences and lifestyle, ThredUp is one of the easiest and most well-rounded online thrift stores. The platform is intuitive for sellers—no resale experience required—and helps buyers find one-of-a-kind items that fit their personal style.

Where can I buy used handbags?

ThredUp is the ultimate place to find preloved handbags. Whether you’re looking for shoulder bags or clutches, you’ll find an extensive selection from trusted brands. Browse high-quality Coach bags or Chanel purses—all for up to 90% off the retail price.

Where can I find high-quality used designer clothing?

Check ThredUp for like-new designer clothing and accessories from brands like Ralph Lauren, Burberry, and Louis Vuitton. A dedicated team carefully inspects and authenticates each piece, so you can score luxury fashion items affordably and sustainably.