8 Best Thrift Stores in NYC for Budget Shoppers

‍

Thrifting in New York City (NYC) is more than just a way to save money—it’s an integral part of the fashion scene in the city that never sleeps. Whether you’re hunting for a one-of-a-kind vintage band tee or a designer jacket that looks like it belongs in Bella Hadid’s closet, the best thrift stores in NYC are filled with hidden treasures that’ll keep you looking fab while reducing your fashion footprint. 

NYC is a thrift shopping paradise, with every borough offering its own secondhand gems, from Williamsburg’s trendy boutiques to the jam-packed racks of Greenwich Village. Read on for a guide to eight of the city’s top spots so you can thrift in New York like a pro. 

8 best thrift shops in New York City

Find affordable, sustainable clothing and accessories at these eight thrift shops in NYC. 

1. Buffalo Exchange 

Buffalo Exchange, established in 1974 in Tucson, Arizona, has become synonymous with thrift shopping culture, with some of their largest stores in NYC. This buy, sell, and trade store has multiple locations across the city, including the vibrant East Village. 

Buffalo Exchange shoppers can expect a diverse selection of secondhand clothing, from contemporary brands to unique vintage pieces. The company’s commitment to charity makes them a wise choice for socially-conscious fashion enthusiasts, as they give millions to local arts, environmental, and women's organizations each year. 

2. Housing Works 

Housing Works, founded in 1999, is a non-profit organization that operates several thrift shops throughout New York City. The proceeds support people affected by HIV/AIDS and homelessness. Housing Works has 10 locations in New York offering an array of clothing, furniture, and jewelry. Each store has a curated selection of items that are in good condition. 

3. Awoke Vintage 

Awoke Vintage began as a market stall in Australia. This thrift shop then made its way to NYC, launching a storefront in Williamsburg in 2012. They’ve since expanded to multiple NYC locations. 

Awoke Vintage specializes in vintage clothing from the ’80s and ’90s. You can buy everything from preloved leather jackets to used sneakers in-store and online. 

4. 10 ft. Single by Stella Dallas 

Every day is National Thrifting Day when you shop at 10 ft Single by Stella Dallas. This NYC thrift shop in Williamsburg, only a short subway ride from Manhattan, is a treasure trove for vintage lovers. 

10 ft. Single by Stella Dallas was established in the early 2000s. They offer an extensive collection of clothing and accessories spanning many decades, from vintage tees to puffer vests and button-up shirts. Their selection caters to all genders, and they also offer vintage furniture, textiles, and antique clothing. 

5. Beacon’s Closet 

If you’re looking for resale shops in NYC, try Beacon’s Closet. They began in Brooklyn in 1997 and have since expanded to multiple NYC locations, including Park Slope and Green Point. This consignment shop is known for their color-coordinated racks filled with contemporary and vintage pieces. Shoppers can find everything from designer labels to everyday wear, all in excellent condition. 

At Beacon’s Closet, you can buy, sell, and trade clothing, shoes, and accessories. They pay 30% cash or 50% store credit for the prices assigned to your items. 

6. L Train Vintage 

L Train Vintage, named after the busiest train going between Manhattan and Brooklyn, is a staple vintage thrift shop in NY. They operate several locations, including in the bustling East Village, trendy Bushwick, and laid-back Crown Heights. This family-owned business offers a broad range of high-quality vintage clothing, with new drops three times weekly at all their storefronts. 

L Train Vintage is known for their affordable prices and impressive selection. From flannel shirts to vintage suits, you’ll find a range of styles ideal for building fashionable, sustainable outfits on a budget. 

7. Crossroads Trading Co. 

This buy, sell, and trade store has locations in Manhattan, in Brooklyn, and across the United States. They offer a curated selection of trendy clothing and accessories for cash or store credit, so shoppers can find current styles at reduced prices. 

Crossroads Trading Co.’s commitment to sustainability and secondhand fashion make them a popular choice among eco-conscious New Yorkers. Their boutique-style storefronts offer a friendly, upscale vibe, and you’ll find the same brands there as you do at many of the glitzy department stores on 5th Avenue or Lexington. 

8. Cure Thrift Shop 

Cure Thrift Shop is a curated vintage shop situated in Manhattan. Founded in 2008, they offer a mix of vintage and modern clothing, accessories, antiques, and home goods. 

This NYC thrift store was established to support diabetes research, with all proceeds going toward Diabetes Empowerment International and similar organizations. Their eclectic inventory and philanthropic mission have garnered a loyal customer base, particularly among thrifters who prefer giving back. You’ll get lost among the books, furniture, T-shirts, and more. 

Perfect the art of thrift shopping with ThredUp

NYC thrift shops are a gateway to sustainable, budget-friendly fashion. Whether digging through racks in Flushing or uncovering a designer gem off Washington Square, thrifting makes it easy to refresh your wardrobe while reducing waste. 

If you prefer shopping online or don’t live in the Big Apple, ThredUp brings the best thrift store finds to wherever you are. Browse our online shop for thousands of curated pieces, from everyday staples to designer bags, with the help of our AI-powered search tools. Use our Style Chat feature for personalized outfit advice and our Fashion Footprint Calculator to track your impact on the planet. 

You can also purge your closet with our Clean Out bags. Just order, fill with clean clothes, and return to ThredUp to earn cash or credit.

{{inline-banner}}

FAQ 

Is it cheaper to thrift?

Shopping at thrift stores is generally more affordable than purchasing new items. These stores offer a wide range of secondhand clothing and accessories at lower prices, making it more accessible for budget-conscious shoppers. Some thrift shops offer special discount days and seasonal deals, making scoring great finds at low prices even easier. 

How can I get quality clothes at thrift stores?

To find quality clothes at thrift stores, consider these tips: 

• Scrutinize items: Look for any signs of wear, tear, or damage. Check for intact seams, working zippers, and stain-free fabric to ensure the item is in good condition.
• Research the store’s reputation: You might have better luck at stores known for curating high-quality items than a bargain bin retailer. 
• Visit frequently: Many thrift stores’ inventories change regularly, so frequent visits increase your chance of finding quality pieces. You might even make a friend among the staff!
• Be patient and open-minded: Thrifting requires time and a willingness to explore different brands and styles. If an entire store feels overwhelming, search for the sections that best match your style, such as vintage jackets or curated denim.

What’s the difference between a thrift store and a vintage store?

While both offer secondhand items, here are a few key differences: 

• Thrift stores typically accept donated items and sell them at low prices. They offer a variety of clothing, regardless of age or style. Many non-profit shops, like Housing Works, also support charitable causes with their proceeds. 
• Vintage stores specialize in clothing and items from specific eras, usually at least 20 years old. The pieces are often curated for style and quality, resulting in higher prices, but more standout fits. 

Does NYC have good thrifting?

New York City has a thriving thrifting scene with many thrift shops, vintage stores, and flea markets. Neighborhoods like Williamsburg and the East Village are hotspots for unique finds, from ’90s-inspired items to designer consignment. Whether you’re hunting for affordable basics or one-of-a-kind finds, NYC’s diverse thrift shops deliver the goods. 

‍